What is the philosophy of cosmicism and how is it used to convey a sense of dread in both The Shadow Over Innsmouth and The Colour out of Space?
Cosmicism is a philosophy that was developed by H.P. Lovecraft and had a significant presence in his work. The idea of cosmicism is “that there is no recognizable divine presence, such as a god, in the universe, and that humans are particularly insignificant in the larger scheme of intergalactic existence.” That there were eons before us and there will be eons after us, we are just a temporary spec of dust on a planet (C. R. WILEY, 2017). Cosmicism is used very effectively in Lovecraft’s work to convey dread.
The Shadow over Innsmouth was written in 1931 but publicised later due to Lovecraft’s issues he had with it. Despite Lovecraft’s dislike for the story it still conveys dread through cosmicism. The story has many implications that stick with the reader after they have finished reading it. The first is that Robert is able to let go of his humanity. At the end of the story despite knowing he is going to lose his humanity and become a Deep One, he is able to accept this and even look at it optimistically. It implies through cosmicism, that we as human beings are able give up on something that should be a core part of ourselves, that we are so insignificant, that an unknown force can simply take away our self worth and values. The next implication is that the deep ones are able to make humans betray each other, that our bond as a species can be easily broken by the unknown, and make us prioritize them over our own kind. The next implication is that Robert had no control over his life from the very beginning. It was an inevitability that Robert was helpless to stop regardless as to whether he found out about it or not. According to cosmicism, there is no god, and the other humans are more inclined to take the side of the deep ones then robert, meaning there is absolutely nothing that can save Robert from his fate.
This trend of cosmicism in lovecraft’s work continues in The colour out of space. Some of the implications here are similar to The Shadow over innsmouth when cosmicism is considered, such as the humans being powerless against the creature, Gardner is unable to protect his family, his livestock, or himself, and the people who go to the farm are equally powerless and all they can do is run away. The alien was simply able to impose itself on humanity without consequence. The humans being unable to perceive the creature, or not being able to process it without feinting is another returning feature. In this story we can only perceive the alien as being a color, no shape, or size or texture, a color is all our brains can process. The last dread setting idea is that the odds of what happened to the Gardners was a cosmically incalculable number, the meteor could have landed in another state, or country, or planet, or could have ended up in a completely different galaxy. Yet it landed in the gardners farm, the implication is that no matter how unlikely it is in the cosmic expanse, it could still happen to you.
C. R. WILEY. (2017, August 24). Lovecraft’s Cosmicism: What it Is, How It Works, and Why It Fails. https://www.patheos.com/blogs/gloryseed/2017/08/lovecrafts-cosmicism-works-fails/
Lovecraft, H. P. (1927). The color out of space.
Lovecraft, H. P. (1936). The shadow over innsmouth